“Superbad,” the latest release from the hot-streaking camp of producer Judd Apatow (“The 40 Year Old Virgin, Knocked Up”), written by Seth Rogan & Evan Goldberg and directed by Greg Mottola, is unquestionably hilarious. We are in the midst of a creative explosion from Apatow, one which recalls the career of Harold Ramis in the eighties. Ramis was at the heart of an absurd level of quality comedy during those years, everything from “Animal House” to “Meatballs” to “Caddyshack” and “Stripes.” Often working within low budgets, marked by casual staging and fairly artless cinematography, Ramis often infused these films with a quiet, everyman quality not seen before: the orgin of the schlub hero. Apatow clearly feels some kinship with him, even replicating a faux low budget look, and it seems no coincidence that he cast Ramis as Seth Rogan’s father in “Knocked Up,” which played almost like a warped remake of “Stripes,” with fatherhood standing in for the United States Army. Only somehow Bill Murray and Harold Ramis invading East Berlin in an armored RV seems more realistic than Katherine Heigel having sex with Seth Rogan. In fact, there are often moments of wish fulfillment like this undercutting the more “realistic” tone and questioning Apatow’s role as rightful heir to Ramis, and no, I’m not talking about the Age of Aquarius dance number which closes out “The 40 Year Old Virgin.” In the world of Apatow, “reality” is often overcome by fantasy.
Now comes “Superbad,” the filthy, tender tale of two best friends, Seth & Evan (Jonah Hill & Michael Cera), on the verge of high school graduation, going through separation anxiety and sexual panic over the course of one nutty night. The main character’s names are obviously not the only autobiographical elements in a film with a decidedly unromantic bent. Clearly inspired by the looking-to-shed-our-virginity subgenre of teen comedies popularized in the 80′s (“Going All the Way, The Last American Virgin, Fast Times at Ridgemont High”) , “Superbad” opens with a Columbia logo from that era (shades of “Grindhouse”) and promptly sets about deconstructing conventions dating back almost twenty-five years. You’ll find no Ferris Buellers here, just the kinds of guys usally reduced to sight gags often involving thick glasses, runny noses and pants pulled up way too high. I’ve read that Rogan & Goldberg began writing this back in high school, fueled by the wide gap between the idealized visions they were seeing on the big screen and the crap they were actually going through between english and gym. It’s revenge of the nerds.
The two boys at the center of the film are awkward and unpopular and ultimately (spoiler) fail to accomplish what they set out to do, which only serves to highlight their endearing humanity. We are truly living in the golden age of the geek, where every comic book collector (present company included) is a potential auteur and, onscreen anyway, the lower you rank on the social scale, the more likely you are to be OUR HERO. This is a reflection of the strong movement towards “realism” in pop culture these days, which is really nothing more than a result of shifting perspectives. History is written by the winners and right now the winners are the losers. However, “Superbad” has another storyline, one which directly contrasts “reality.”
Christopher Mintz Plasse plays Fogel, a geek’s geek, who is on first glance even more socially inept than the two main characters. He acquires a fake I.D. near the start of the movie and Seth and Evan press him into using it to buy liquor so they can get a couple of girls drunk in the hopes of getting laid. Fogel’s decision to use the one word moniker “McLovin” on his bogus Hawian driver’s license, a cooler-than-cool persona he aspires to, results in a self fulfilling prophecy. Caught up in a robbery at the local liquor store, Fogel encounters two cops, one played by co-writer Seth Rogan and the other by Bill Hader, a talented recent addition to the cast of “Saturday Night Live.” From this point on, Fogel is transformed into “McLovin,” and everything he touches turns to gold in a manner which would turn Ferris green with envy. This is where “reality” jumps out the window and we are treated to a succession of increasingly outlandish events as Fogel and the cops get sidetracked. These are two very unlikely peace officers, the type which do not occur in nature, drunkenly careening from place to place and bending over backwards for Fogel, who they seemingly hold in great esteem, for no real reason. And here is where the film’s understated, realistic tone falters, undercut by what feels like the most clichéd elements of those films which Rogan & Goldberg originally rebelled against. This is certainly the point, but it slows the film’s momentum and deeply undercuts the sweet relatability of the rest of the film. This element is pushed to a head-scratching extreme which sees the cops setting fire to their own cruiser in order to cover up their night of incompetent debauchery. Here there is a real sense of trying to wed the fantasy of the 80′s sex comedies with the more mundane tone we’ve associated with Apatow since he emerged fully formed with his portrait of dork life on TV’s “Freaks & Geeks.” These elements don’t mesh well together, not anymore than Katherine Heigl would mesh with Seth Rogan, as “Knocked Up” would have us believe. Let’s face it, there is no woman in this universe who aspires to an on-air job with E! and also finds husband material in an unemployed, overweight pothead with a jewfro. And in “Superbad,” Rogan’s alter ego (Jonah Hill) is PURSUED by Jules (Emma Stone), a girl so out of his league that her attraction to him calls everything into question. At first, it seems that she is only interested in Seth as a means to aquiring booze, but we find (spoiler) that it is simply a way of getting close to him. This is the point at which all illusions of realism are shattered. Luckily, it is also pretty damn close to the conclusion.
I can’t help but catch a whiff of the geek’s unrequited desire to hang with the cool kids in this blatant wish fulfillment. Come on Apatow, I know you’re married to quite a dish (Leslie Mann, who was hilarious in both “The 40 Year Old Virgin” and “Knocked Up”) but, no matter what Tom Petty says, losers hardly ever get lucky.